Used Car Values – How to Sell Your Car at the Right Price

Just a month ago I completed the sale of my 2008 Subaru Forester. After making payments on it for 2+ years, I decided that I wanted something different, something that I had owned before. So I bought myself a 2007 Mini Cooper S that is still under the factory warranty with just over 40,000 miles on it. I couldn’t be happier with my decision! But I digress – I want to talk about selling my Subaru and the steps I went through in order to discover what it was worth, what I could possibly get for it, and then finally deciding on a buyer.

The first thing I did was find out how much I still owed on the car – this was my “I must at least get this for the car so I can pay it off entirely and then buy something else” price. Luckily, I made a heck of a deal on the car when I bought it, paying just $19,000 out the door including taxes/fees – this for a car that had a sticker price of almost $24,000 plus tax. So right away, I knew that my “what I owe to residual value ratio” was pretty good. Add in the fact that I always paid more than the minimum payment on the loan each month, and my final dollar amount that I owed as of a month ago was $13,109. This was how much I had to get for the car in a sale to break even and walk away clean. It was my bottom price point.

The next thing I did was start looking up the residual value of a 2008 Subaru Forester. There are many places on the internet to do this kind of research, but my personal favorites (and the ones I find come closest to the truthful price) are Kelly Blue Book and Edmunds. All you have to do is go to the sites, enter your zip code, make/model/year of the car you are learning about, how many miles you have on it, and check off any extras that your car may have been sold with. For the record, my car was a 2008 Forester with 40,000 miles in very good condition. Trade-in value is what you can expect to get selling it to a dealer and Private Party value is what you can expect to get selling it to an individual. This is what each site told me that my car was worth:

Kelly Blue Book:
Trade-In Value in Good Condition – $13,550
Private Party Value in Good Condition – $15,815

Trade-In Value in Good Condition – $13,982
Private Party Value in Good Condition – $15,856

Thankfully, both the trade-in and the private party price is above the “what I owe” dollar amount of $13,109, so I knew I could sell the car and at least walk away without owing any money – and possibly even pocket a little extra. I went ahead and listed it on the local Craigslist here in Colorado, received a few emails and had some local interest – but no sale. So I took it to my favorite last resort car buying company – Carmax. I have bought and sold cars to them before, it’s a very painless and seamless process, and they will give you a fair price on the car you are selling. After they appraised my car, they came back with their offer:


Sold. I get to walk away with a few extra hundred bucks back, I get a fair price for my car, and I don’t have to haggle or deal with individual people trying to get the best price or arrange financing. As an added bonus, my car was still registered in New Mexico, and thus I didn’t have to pay to have it transferred here for a private buyer. I handed CarMax the keys and walked away. Sure, they will sell it on their lot for a lot more than that, but I just wanted to sell the car for a fair price and pay off the balance. Goal achieved!

As you can see, finding out the value of your car and then selling it can take you on many different paths. The key is to explore several different ways of finding out (and running) the numbers to make any deal work for you. If Kelly Blue Book and Edmunds don’t work for you, you can also check out NADA or Cars.com to get even more information.

Good luck!

Like this article? Please consider subscribing to my full feed RSS. Or, if you would prefer, you can subscribe by Email and have new posts sent directly to your inbox by entering your email address in the box below. Your email will only be used to deliver a daily email and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Comments (7)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Stephan says:

    this was defintiely the easy way to sell your car, but dont you think an extra grand or 1500 would have come in handy? im sure you could have waited, placed some ads and gotten more money for it. were you in a rush to sell the car and get your mini?

  2. David says:

    Sure – if I had actually gotten it. I would have had to get someone’s money, send it to the lender, wait for the title to come back, then complete the sale. And it could have taken months to sell the car, especially with spring here and residents not thinking about AWD. This was seamless and there was no guarantee I would have even gotten what I wanted had I sold it privately.I just wanted it done. 🙂

  3. If you have the patience to sell your used car on your own, you will for the most part always get more money than if you trade it in.

    Its definitely the way to go.

  4. Marissa says:

    This is a great method you used to get the most for your money. I was not aware of the Kelly Blue Book website. I will use it for future reference.

  5. Thanks for another avenue to check out with the Carmax. We are in the process of buying a new car (shopping just this morning), while they would love to get their hands on my ‘pristine’ Mercury Mountaineer (which is a true little-old lady only to the grocery driven car as my dear husband likes to call my poor suv) i will in no way trade it in and take a beating while they make a mint. We will attempt to sell outright but with the economy the way it is and the suv’s sitting around because everyone is going for good gas mileage cars now we may be sitting on it. I will check into the Carmax as another alternative. Thanks!

  6. […] Used Car Values: How to Sell Your Car at the Right Price @ My Two Dollars […]

  7. Michael says:

    If you’re looking to buy a new car Kelly Blue Book, Edmonds and Truecar are the best sites to use.